Missing The Point, Again

by | May 26, 2020

The government’s trumpeted new First Homes scheme proposes to give key workers and first-time buyers in England the chance to buy a home in their local area at a 30% discount….a saving of up to £100,00 in some cases.

The Coronavirus drama has, if nothing else, taught us who the nation’s heroes really are. Hopefully in the New Norm people will care a lot, lot less about reality TV stars, socialites and footballers and more about the people in society that keep what actually matters running – the key workers. Add onto that the first-time buyers, increasingly squeezed out of the market through simple supply and demand economics and, on the surface, the First Homes scheme is a sweet idea. Helping those that need the help most.

While the exact details of how the scheme will operate are still unclear, the Government has indicated that it will impose a price cap on the properties available through First Homes to ensure the initiative helps those who would benefit most from it – those at the bottom of the homebuying ladder.

On that level it’s a great idea…but real life rarely does what you want it to and there’s often a catch. Take a look at the Help to Buy scheme that’s been running for a number of years now. The government will proudly announce that the scheme has helped tens of thousands of first time buyers onto the ladder. And indeed it has…at the cost of a rise in house prices in the ‘affordable’ sector the scheme is intended to help.

Again, it boils down to supply and demand. Well-meaning schemes swell the numbers of would-be buyers; new housing delivery fails to keep pace; prices go up; some homeowners climb onto the ladder whilst others become even more marginalised or unable to move upwards; the biggest winners are the developers, able to charge higher and higher for their product.

Will the First Homes scheme have a similar effect on the market? I suspect it will. Great for those that can actually take advantage of it – and good luck to them – but not so good for everybody else.

Incentives to buy should be preceded by incentives to build. Get the housing stock there in the first place, then reward those that truly deserve it with incentives to buy. At Hilltop a large number of the units for which our developers are seeking property development finance qualify for the Help to Buy equity loan, which is great, but the age-old problem will remain for some time yet: not enough homes are being built. Deal with that and everything else becomes plainer sailing.


Interesting article? Put our experience to work…

Traditional Development Finance Lenders vs Progressive Funding Partners? 5 Big Differences

In the 13 years since the global financial crisis, there’s been a dramatic change in property development finance. Where once banks acted...

Eco-friendly Development: Using Modular Construction and Tech to Reduce Carbon Footprint

Eco-friendly development is housebuilding’s trump card in meeting the 2008 Climate Change Act’s targeted 80% reduction in greenhouse...

Sustainable Residential Development – Ashford, Kent

With ever-increasing importance on the environmental and social credentials of construction, Hilltop’s lending focuses on affordable,...

Hilltop Credit Partners completes £11.2m loan for redevelopment of Grade II listed hotel in Torquay, Devon

Funds advised by Hilltop Credit Partners have completed an £11.2m loan to Ascena Developments for the redevelopment of the historic Grade...

Finance and available capital in an uncertain market

Paul Oberschneider gives a keynote interview for real estate media platform Bisnow's digital seminar "Finance and Available Capital in an...

Hilltop to deploy up to £300m to fund UK house building, following backing from Metropolitan Real Estate

Hilltop has secured investment from Metropolitan Real Estate, the global real estate multi-manager platform. As part of this, Hilltop will...

UK House Prices Snapshot

Official UK house prices for December 2020 were released by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) yesterday. The data shows prices...

As seen in...

Fintech Finance logo
Logo - CoStar
Logo - Business Leader
Logo - Development Finance Today
Logo - Real Estate Capital
Logo - CoStar
Logo - Business Leader
Logo - Development Finance Today
Logo - Real Estate Capital
Logo - CoStar
Logo - Business Leader
Logo - Development Finance Today
Logo - Bridging Loan Directory
Logo - Property Week
Logo - IPE Real Assets
Logo - Business Daily News

Register your interest here


Let’s talk! Get in touch on +44 (0) 203 903 6369 
or leave us a message below and we’ll get right back to you.

7 + 13 =

  • Share This